Do You Think Immigrants Should Serve?

[AgnesIO]

I heard this very good statement the other day and no matter which country your from (Uk, Us, Canada, Australia, NZ, etc...) they all have immigration problems and the statement said, why not make all immigrants over 20 serve in the arm forces (not necesserialy fighting but maybe helping with other things such as working in the munitions departments...) whats your idea?

This is possibly the worlds, most stupid, ridiculous idea I hve heard.

Some immigrants are hard working citizens - 10x better than half the **** we have over here. I mean come off it? If you moved to a different country for a better life and then got told 'u gotta fite for us mayte.' You would leave.

[Nixt]

No. The British Army runs well as it is without forcing people to work for it. In fact it is why it runs so well, because the people that are there want to be there. That's why we have the best Army in the world..

[-:Undertaker:-]

Let them live there life, they have every right to be here as we do, we all have different parts of us, like from Germany, Russia, Ireland and so on, and that doesn't make us any different from each other. We are all one race and we should live like it. The world used to be one nation, Panjia I think it was called, so we are all just one race.

Humans were not around then and the British welfare system didn't exist - the world was a far different place to now.

[Mickword]

Yeah but as long as we are human does it matter?

[-:Undertaker:-]

Yeah but as long as we are human does it matter?

Indeed it does matter.

Finance, well-being, personal well-being, quality of life, and public opinion all matters.

[Mickword]

I take that into consideration, but really you can't make people who do have a right to be here to help out the army, who is doing fine. Can you really.

[Jay.]

Nobody is going to come to UK to defend for our country now, are they?

I don't think they should be allowed in my opinion. Why exactly should immigrants come to the country then fight for us? It's not right. What if we go into war with someone, say Germany (random country) then a German person who is a solider for us, goes to war. They'd surely friendly fire?

[Ardemax]

Jay, im not being mean or anything, but i don't like people with the kind of opinion like yours.

The reason being is you think that immigrants just bring trouble? When actually, they work harder than a lot of people born here, they will put in more effort (usually) to stay here.

Maybe they're fleeing from a war in their country? Do you want to kill people by not letting them settle here?

Think about it.

[-:Undertaker:-]

Jay, im not being mean or anything, but i don't like people with the kind of opinion like yours.

The reason being is you think that immigrants just bring trouble? When actually, they work harder than a lot of people born here, they will put in more effort (usually) to stay here.

Maybe they're fleeing from a war in their country? Do you want to kill people by not letting them settle here?

Think about it.

I know you and the left do not approve of common sense opinions, hence why you named UKIP racist and refuse to accept the BNP have a mandate from the electorate, and are therefore entitled to sit on Question Time. I have said before and I will say it again, anybody who does not agree with the left is labelled racist, homophobic or xenophobic and you have just proven it with what you have just stated above, you refuse to accept that people have other opinions to yours.

There are 150+ other states' in the world, why should the United Kingdom (which has crippling debts, a welfare system that can be abused and high crime rates) cater for the rest of the world. We tried to help Africa, the Middle East and Asia - but alas, they threw us out after we built them hospitals, roads, capitals and everything else.

[Ardemax]

im sorry but our efforts to "help" weren't "helping" as in giving resources, more like invading..

so you're calling me racist because i think BNP should not appear on question time?

i really dont get it? :S