Joe makes Number 1

[kk.]

[/B]


Explain how? What exactly did he do to deserve this xmas number one? I'll tell you what he did. Nothing. He was a contestant on some stupid show, and got given a career.

Anyway, number one, shame it wasn't xmas.

Good singer. Good singers deserve number ones. What exactly did rage do to deserve Xmas number one?

[Alkaz]

Joe is not really an artist he is just good at karaoke

LMAO! His voice definately not suited for karaoke.

[Cheryl]

I love the way Lottie said finally as if it's been ages :S 1 week

[Callum.]

He's a good singer, but can't see him going amazingly far. He seemed really cocky in articles and interviews after winning. And I read somewhere that he slated the band at the start of the week, there was no respect.

[Black_Apalachi]

Good singer. Good singers deserve number ones. What exactly did rage do to deserve Xmas number one?

Built their own career maybe? I can't believe you would even criticise an artist's credibility when they've been around for that long and are still this popular :S. I said from the beginning this was not about Joe McElderry personally, but the more people complain and act bitter, the more it's going to turn into something personal against him.

So basically, if you're a Joe fan, stop arguing because it's just going to make HIM hated rather than Cowell/X-Factor, OR if you're just anti-RATM, stop arguing because you're bitter. RATM is Christmas #1, deal with it.

He's a good singer, but can't see him going amazingly far. He seemed really cocky in articles and interviews after winning. And I read somewhere that he slated the band at the start of the week, there was no respect.

I agree with every part of that post.

[Richie]

He still failed to keep up the xfactor tradition

[kk.]

Built their own career maybe? I can't believe you would even criticise an artist's credibility when they've been around for that long and are still this popular :S. I said from the beginning this was not about Joe McElderry personally, but the more people complain and act bitter, the more it's going to turn into something personal against him.

So basically, if you're a Joe fan, stop arguing because it's just going to make HIM hated rather than Cowell/X-Factor, OR if you're just anti-RATM, stop arguing because you're bitter. RATM is Christmas #1, deal with it.



I agree with every part of that post.

I think you missed my point lol. I didn't say they didn't deserve a number one, I was merely asking what makes them deserve a number one, and was hoping that he'd come out with the same answer of, they are good. Thus meaning, that joe also deserves a number one because he's a good singer.

[Black_Apalachi]

I think you missed my point lol. I didn't say they didn't deserve a number one, I was merely asking what makes them deserve a number one, and was hoping that he'd come out with the same answer of, they are good. Thus meaning, that joe also deserves a number one because he's a good singer.

Nope, I understood and answered your question.

[kk.]

You obviously didn't if you're saying that I'm disclaiming their credibility.. I was merely saying that joe deserved a number one, just as any other artist does.

As I've said before rob, I wouldve preferred if ratm didn't get number one, purely on the fact that it's, personally, a horrible song, from a horrible band. I perhaps wouldve supported the campaign had it had been a different song, one that was more christmassy maybe. If someone pens a Christmas song for next year then maybe I'll support them. (even tho x factor prob won't get number one next year due to them probably ending a week early)

[theman0001]

LMAO! His voice definately not suited for karaoke.

as far as i can work out he just sang the words to a song which had already been released.

As I've said before rob, I wouldve preferred if ratm didn't get number one, purely on the fact that it's, personally, a horrible song, from a horrible band.

I personally think the song is good and the band is good