Should X Factor reject Gamu Nhengu be deported from the UK?

[Samantha]

At the end of the day, people may want her to stay, people may want her to go.
But if you really think about it, if she wasn't on X Factor it wouldn't be any different, she would have to go back as her VISA was turned down.
Like above just because she has a good voice, and appeared on T.V she should have to go back.

[Josh]

Why on earth would she be allowed to stay over others who haven't claimed thousands of pounds? Oh... yeah, she doesn't. She's had her go and she ****** it up so she and her family face the consequences.

[Conservative,]

This is a hard one to be fair. She wasn't the actual one claiming, and she's now of an age where she can take care of herself, get a job ect. so I'm actually not sure.

Certainly her mum should be deported for fraud & illegal immigration...but I haven't checked to see if Gamu tried to renew her visa or not...but as long as she has a valid visa for her, then I don't see why not, because it wasn't her who committed it. But if not then yes she should be deported.

Basically, in my opinion, if she doesn't have a valid visa, then yes deport her, she's no different to any other illegal immigrant and quite frankly we don't need anymore of them. But if she has a valid visa, don't because it wasn't her who claimed the benefits.

[Apple]

This is a hard one to be fair. She wasn't the actual one claiming, and she's now of an age where she can take care of herself, get a job ect. so I'm actually not sure.

Certainly her mum should be deported for fraud & illegal immigration...but I haven't checked to see if Gamu tried to renew her visa or not...but as long as she has a valid visa for her, then I don't see why not, because it wasn't her who committed it. But if not then yes she should be deported.

Basically, in my opinion, if she doesn't have a valid visa, then yes deport her, she's no different to any other illegal immigrant and quite frankly we don't need anymore of them. But if she has a valid visa, don't because it wasn't her who claimed the benefits.

She is just as much to blame for the benefit fraud, she knew about it and was happy to spend the money they were getting illegally.

[Conservative,]

She is just as much to blame for the benefit fraud, she knew about it and was happy to spend the money they were getting illegally.

You could argue she was too young to understand at the time, and is it proved she knew about it?

[AgnesIO]

Claimed benefits illegally (well her mother did), visa has run out.

Yes she should - it doesn't matter if she has been on X Factor - she should go.

[flatface]

She is just as much to blame for the benefit fraud, she knew about it and was happy to spend the money they were getting illegally.

I might of missed something here, but can you link me to the source that says she knew about all this illegal activity?

[Samantha]

Her visa ran out as asked above. I can't remember where I saw it but it said that she had been declined the renew.

[Conservative,]

To put my position as simply as possible...

if SHE DID actually break the law - ie; didn't renew her VISA or w/e...then yes, send her back...

if it WASN'T HER (ie; her mother claimed the benefits - not her, and she still has a VISA), then I think she should stay..but I don't know the details so yh

[Apple]

I might of missed something here, but can you link me to the source that says she knew about all this illegal activity?

So did she think that her mother had found the money or something? It's insulting her intelligence to say that she wouldn't of been wondering where her mother was getting the money from.