New X Factor UK Judges

[Kyle]

I don't really understand what everybody's problem is with the Tulisa girl?? Don't you remember what Cheryl was like before x factor? Gary Barlow is a legend so should be good.

[Eoin247]

I don't even know all the judges lol. Who's this Tulisa you speak of ? Disapointed that Simon and Cheryl left.

Problem with it for me is that I guess everyone will try to make it as the nice guy, so there won't be much honest criticism. (bit like the current BGT lineup)

To be fair Louis (who is still a judge on it) gave quite a lot of honest criticism. Cheryl was the only really 100% "nice no matter what" judge on the old panel.

Danni is and was the worst judge ever to be on the X Factor.

Of course, we are yet to see the chav from n Dubz as a judge.

Never liked Danni as a judge, she threatened to resign when she didn't get what she wanted.

[peteyt]

I think instead of changing the judges they should have changed the actual concept and allowed actual bands to play, allowing real music and real talent.

The big problem with the x factor and in my opinion, why a lot of its winners often failed, is they simply cover song after song and don't really get a chance to try their own stuff, although most probably can't.

If they allowed actual groups to come on it would be in my opinion a lot better. I want to see real acts with real music, not manufactured artists.

[ifuseekamy]

I don't really understand what everybody's problem is with the Tulisa girl?? Don't you remember what Cheryl was like before x factor? Gary Barlow is a legend so should be good.

Me neither I saw some show with the Tulisa girl on about having parents with disabilities and she seemed really genuine and sweet.

[paddy140]

I will not watch the x-Factor now

[GommeInc]

Hopefully it'll never appear after this, the X Factor is frustrating to watch as well as what happens at the end, the winners don't really go on to become anything amazing and Christmas No.1s should be reserved for bands/artists who have worked their arses off for the weeks running up to Christmas, no some nobody who will be forgotten weeks after

[orientalframe?]

Don't like the sound of the line up at all, the X Factor just wont be the same, and has gone down the pan.

[Conservative,]

Tbh that line up imo is good. I know most people won't like it but I do. Tulisa will bring a different view on things because of her genre etc. + she's fit so im happy. Gary Barlow is a musical legend hands down. Louis...well you can't argue he's been a judge from the beginning. And Kelly Rowland...I don't like her but I think she'll be a decent judge.

[Jordan]

It's going to be different, is all I can say. It will be weird without the judges we are known to have. Though I'm not saying this is bad until I've actually seen them!

[Eric]

Eww. Where's Simon

I dont like all of them.