DISCUSS X FACTOR 2011

[wiktoria]

get your gaga poster out ready for saturday and sunday cos GAGA is on our screens!!!!!!!!!!!!!

hahah i'm definitely watching it saturday and sunday can't wait!!

[Catzsy]

It has been a bit of a mess up this year - I don't think they should have booted these contestants in the first place so hopefully they will at least have a chance now.

[:odey:]

She's doing 'Marry the Night'. If she wants to get anywhere with the song chart wise, she needs to release the video either this week or on Monday. If she continues to delay it, the promotional slot on X Factor will be a complete and utter waste. A fine example of how it could bugger up is Katy Perry's "The One That Got Away" - we're still waiting on the bloody video!!

Video today though, it's extremely exciting...

And, I'm not sure they would be able to bring anyone back in to the competition,

It would be unfair on all those who voted to boot them out!

[peteyt]

Video today though, it's extremely exciting...

And, I'm not sure they would be able to bring anyone back in to the competition,

It would be unfair on all those who voted to boot them out!

They brought back one of the singers from Nu Vibe and added them to The Risk.

[Stephen]

Anyone else think this vote who should return thing is unfair?

The person who returns would of done nothing to get this far. Johnny should be brought back because he was the last person out AND didn't get voted out by the public

[TheCasualSpy]

i couldn't believe my luck when frankie got kicked out but poor johnny still didn't come back in

---------- Post added 11-11-2011 at 10:56 PM ----------

Anyone else think this vote who should return thing is unfair?

The person who returns would of done nothing to get this far. Johnny should be brought back because he was the last person out AND didn't get voted out by the public

you're right johnny should be let back in as the last contestant to leave

[:odey:]

Anyone else think this vote who should return thing is unfair?

The person who returns would of done nothing to get this far. Johnny should be brought back because he was the last person out AND didn't get voted out by the public

I think this is an absolutely SHOCKING idea, and they're going to get slated for it, so, SO bad.
Especially when the list of people to come back includes people who went in the first live show, it's absolutely ridiculous, poor decision on the producers part.

[peteyt]

I think this is an absolutely SHOCKING idea, and they're going to get slated for it, so, SO bad.
Especially when the list of people to come back includes people who went in the first live show, it's absolutely ridiculous, poor decision on the producers part.

I think it was a problem they couldn't dig out of. They probably would get complaints from people especially people paying for sponsorships if they didn't have the amount of slots and so on and then they'd probably have to refund.

Whoever they brought back be it the old ones or Johnny people would complain.

[Stephen]

People complaining because someone who got sent out in the first week sings one song and gets an instant place in the last 7(?) when all the other contestants had to sing their absolute best to stay in numerous times

or

People complaining because the person who got voted out by the judges and not the public a few days before frankie got booted out returns

If they did let johnny return then the risk fans could easily get their complaints squashed by the fact that the risk got the lowest votes on sunday anyway

[Catzsy]

Anyone else think this vote who should return thing is unfair?

The person who returns would of done nothing to get this far. Johnny should be brought back because he was the last person out AND didn't get voted out by the public

I agree with you but maybe the last four should be brought back and see what happens.