Being 'Fat'

[The Don]

Oh wow, I'm sorry, but are YOU a doctor then?

No, I’m not, but I’m a lot older than you, I’ve looked a lot further into this topic than you have, and I don’t justify and use ‘my friend Amy’ as evidence to support my case which suggests my argument is a lot more valid as I don’t rely on my mum to help me.

Considering my mum is a highschool teacher, she mainly teaches science and she said, and I quote: 'What this person is saying is utterly stupid, as everyone has different body structures, just like boys and girls bone structures are not the same. He/she needs to read up on their facts.'

It’s cute that you got your mum involved, but just because she’s your mum, doesn’t make every sentence that comes out of her mouth fact. Obviously everyone has different body structure, hmm, didn’t I say that in an earlier post of mine? But it’s outrageous to suggest that your friend is 5 stone (double your weight) heavier than you due to her bone density, it’s simply not true.

And also the HEAD of science at our school taught us only last week about this.

I suggest you either pay more attention in school or make a complaint about your head for telling you lies.

And what I said about the fat = overweight is true, considering once again, we learnt it in school.

I’m sorry, but in a ‘grown-up’ discussion, “we learnt it in school" doesn’t cut it as evidence. I could say I studied it in college last week to back up my argument, it doesn’t make it any more true.

Did I ever say she evolved to have a rugby players body from her parents? No. What I said was that SHE is a rugby player, so her body ends up adapting its self in slight ways to suit being a rugby player.

Yes, you said “ her whole family pretty much played rugby, so their bodies changed overtime to suit the roles that they're playing.” Sounds like Darwin’s theory to me?

if she had tiny little bones, like some people, they'd just snap.

Your bones don’t magically grow because you play rugby, so this comments irrelevant.

And about the BMI, you said 'Some BMI calculators may ask you for your body type, but that doesn’t matter' so I just replied that it does matter.. before you start to try make me look like an idiot on saying stuff about BMI, maybe you should remember stuff that you wrote on previous posts?

Yes, your body types only relevant if you’re in the gym lifting weights five times a week. It doesn’t matter if your bone density is slightly higher, it won’t give you an option for that. It will for muscle mass, due to muscle weighing more, thus giving the extra option so you don’t have skewed results. Again, bone density won’t affet your results enough to make BMI irrelevant. It’s only irrelevant if you’re a body builder, which your friend amy, I’m guessing, isn’t, nor is ben…

Oh god. Arguing about something which I'm obviously correct in (as most people know) *removed*

Oh, yeh, sorry I didn’t realise you were correct because ‘your mum said so’ or you ‘learnt it in school’ or your magical friend Amy has magic bones which adapt to suit her rugby playing needs :rolleyes:

You know what? get google out, and find out *removed*

I’d say pot kettle black.

[Cerys]

I really cba to read any of that as I'm tired, but I'm guessing you're still wanting to be the correct one.

Another point which could affect your body is muscle size.
Are you gonna start saying that everyones muscles are the same size and weight, then?

[Sharon]

*REMOVED*

Edited by Chris (Forum Super Moderator): Please do not be rude!

[The Don]

I really cba to read any of that as I'm tired, but I'm guessing you're still wanting to be the correct one.

Another point which could affect your body is muscle size.
Are you gonna start saying that everyones muscles are the same size and weight, then?

Read my post and you'll find out. I'm not 'wanting' to be the correct one, but I find your posts quite absurd and the fact that you can't respond to my last post suggest that I am correct

[Choco]

theres this diet i just did and im still on it but nearly finished it. the dukan diet. since January 9th to this day I've lost 2st and a half

[dbgtz]

Oh wow, I'm sorry, but are YOU a doctor then?

Considering my mum is a highschool teacher, she mainly teaches science and she said, and I quote: 'What this person is saying is utterly stupid, as everyone has different body structures, just like boys and girls bone structures are not the same. He/she needs to read up on their facts.'

And also the HEAD of science at our school taught us only last week about this.

And what I said about the fat = overweight is true, considering once again, we learnt it in school.

Did I ever say she evolved to have a rugby players body from her parents? No. What I said was that SHE is a rugby player, so her body ends up adapting its self in slight ways to suit being a rugby player.
If she had tiny little bones, like some people, they'd just snap.

And about the BMI, you said 'Some BMI calculators may ask you for your body type, but that doesn’t matter' so I just replied that it does matter.. before you start to try make me look like an idiot on saying stuff about BMI, maybe you should remember stuff that you wrote on previous posts?

Oh god. Arguing about something which I'm obviously correct in (as most people know) *removed*

You know what? get google out, and find out *removed*

Oh wow, I'm sorry, but is YOUR MUM a doctor then? The core structure of the human skeleton is the same in each gender (obviously girls and boys differ much more as they age). This means that no one can look fat because they have a different build.

Also to that last sentence about google, you shouldn't believe everything on the internet or from scientists mouths.

I really cba to read any of that as I'm tired, but I'm guessing you're still wanting to be the correct one.

Another point which could affect your body is muscle size.
Are you gonna start saying that everyones muscles are the same size and weight, then?

No **** muscle affects your body, that's pretty much the point of this whole thread.

[FlyingJesus]

Oh god. Arguing about something which I'm obviously correct in (as most people know) *removed*

Actually you claimed that this friend of yours was not overweight despite being 10 stone and the same height as you - unless you happen to be about 5'9" in which case you're likely to be dead at 5 stone then she is almost certainly overweight. Her being a bigger build does not affect this fact to a noticeable degree, unless her bones are made of lead or something.

Maybe YOU should rememer stuff that you've previously written.

[Special]

when i decided to lose some weight for tenerife last month (i was by no means fat or overweight but who doesn't want to lose a pound or 2 before a holiday?) i didn't tell myself i was on a diet i just always watched what i ate. for example i chose a low fat sandwich, orange juice and a bag of fruit for dinner instead of a higher fat sandwich, crisps and cola

all i did was just make that small change and i ended up losing 4 pounds in around 30 days. if you did that combined with exercise (the most important thing for weight loss) you could be losing like 3 pounds a week

[Cerys]

No, me not replying to your posr means I am too busy and tired to answer your post like I said before. And my posts are correct, not absurd.
Goodnight.

Read my post and you'll find out. I'm not 'wanting' to be the correct one, but I find your posts quite absurd and the fact that you can't respond to my last post suggest that I am correct

[The Don]

No, me not replying to your posr means I am too busy and tired to answer your post like I said before. And my posts are correct, not absurd.
Goodnight.

Completely missed the two other posts which completely ruin your argument? I'll paste them here

Actually you claimed that this friend of yours was not overweight despite being 10 stone and the same height as you - unless you happen to be about 5'9" in which case you're likely to be dead at 5 stone then she is almost certainly overweight. Her being a bigger build does not affect this fact to a noticeable degree, unless her bones are made of lead or something.

Maybe YOU should rememer stuff that you've previously written.

Oh wow, I'm sorry, but is YOUR MUM a doctor then? The core structure of the human skeleton is the same in each gender (obviously girls and boys differ much more as they age). This means that no one can look fat because they have a different build.

Also to that last sentence about google, you shouldn't believe everything on the internet or from scientists mouths.



No **** muscle affects your body, that's pretty much the point of this whole thread.