
Lol I too have decided to try and watch season 7 spoiler free. So far I am failing badly.
Gah! Don't quote me, it's making me come back to this thread! Must. Resist. Urge. To. Scroll. Up. And. Read!
I ruined the last series by looking at spoilers - can't let it happen again!![]()
When did she come back? And I do think it maybe was taken a bit far like it was nice that it ended on Bad Wold Bad in S2 but I think because they kept her alive they were always going to bring her back.
As in coming back at Journey's End - I hope they don't do this with Amy - I don't mind occasionally brining some assistants back if its necessary but I felt Rose was just come back to give a load of the people who wanted rose to get with the doctor what they wanted and in the end she got too much. Which is a shame because the character wasn't too bad to begin with
I don't think Karen wants to return. Anyway I think that they should have taken a different direction with bringing Rose back, she should have been incredibly aged or died. I think the main problem with bringing her back, at least for me, was the happy ending they showed and I wish The Doctor would actually lose something properly, at least the DT doctor. It's like he was whining about losing so much, but then next series he would see all the things he cried about. There's no sad endings, it can't sustain all of these happy, fairytale endings and still remain relevant.As in coming back at Journey's End - I hope they don't do this with Amy - I don't mind occasionally brining some assistants back if its necessary but I felt Rose was just come back to give a load of the people who wanted rose to get with the doctor what they wanted and in the end she got too much. Which is a shame because the character wasn't too bad to begin with
Yeah exactly. I mean it just seemed to me RTD listened to all the fans who wanted a relationship with rose and the doctor and decided to do it, and created the whole two doctor thing just so he could do that. It just seemed a waste of an episode. It was a bad episode anyway's in my opinion with the switch destroying all daleks but it made it even worse.I don't think Karen wants to return. Anyway I think that they should have taken a different direction with bringing Rose back, she should have been incredibly aged or died. I think the main problem with bringing her back, at least for me, was the happy ending they showed and I wish The Doctor would actually lose something properly, at least the DT doctor. It's like he was whining about losing so much, but then next series he would see all the things he cried about. There's no sad endings, it can't sustain all of these happy, fairytale endings and still remain relevant.
I felt at times RTD as a fan of doctor who sometimes thought like a fan in the sense that I've had loads of over the top ideas, but fan fiction should be as it is fan fiction. A lot of fan fiction doesn't work in the series. At least Moffat tries to give the audience something, and I suppose not just himself and he isn't scared to try new things.
Looks like Jenny the Doctor's daughter is returning http://www.metro.co.uk/tv/904036-doc...-film-series-7
That's the other Jenny.Looks like Jenny the Doctor's daughter is returning http://www.metro.co.uk/tv/904036-doc...-film-series-7
This is the Jenny from A Good Man Goes To War, who was in love with the Silurian, she's completely not related to The Doctors daughter who was in Series 4![]()
I read about that yesterday but I don't seem to remember her.I'll have to go back and watch it again.
Former General Manager
Former Forum Manager
Former Site Manager
I've left, but I still visit sometimes!
Want to hide these adverts? Register an account for free!