I've had 3 unfair verdicts so far dean

I've had 3 unfair verdicts so far dean
Looks interesting, how does it work though :S
Will
This^Absolutley awful! This power shouldn't be given out willy nilly. It's literally so easy to become a guardian and people have abused it to get to that stage.
I got one bully call and all the user said was 'go away' and the majority of the people voted it was bad? Now that poor person is probably going to get a mute. Got another call and I recognised the people in the chat log. It's a joke.
!) I don't know why people are complaining about how long chatlogs are, you need them to see the whole story lol. Otherwise it'll probably be how the mods these days seem to do it (spot a word and then ban :rolleyes- sarcasm fgs. It may not be interesting to read through it all but it wouldn't be that hard to spot a username
2) Why the **** has everyone had the chance to get it. I know a large majority are going to give honest votes, but the Habbo Helper system got trolled so much and this will be abused just as much. Poor users who have done nothing wrong (e.g. in Red's case said "shut up") are going to be punished if a load of insanely strict Guardians come along all on one case. Like the Safety Patrol but even worse. People will be punished for saying "crap" at this rate tbf.
3) It looks nice and modern, it's genuinely a good look and well designed but it shouldn't be just given out left right and centre to those that can earn a few 'achievements' now and then.
Paul LaFontaine has seriously brought me to the brink of rage. Yes I know someone will say "excuse me you all wanted something like Hobbas back!"!!"!£!" and we did, but an introductory system like this is just stupid. Another reason why I'm not active on the hotel that much anymore lol.
/
You report someone for bullying and then 5 Guardian's pick up the call, review the chat log in 60 seconds and then decide if the user is acting OK, Bad or Severe. OK = no worries, Bad = 15 minute mute and room ban, Severe = sent to moderators.
5 Guardians receive an anonymised chat log, with the reported user marked as "Perpetrator". They then decide whether they thought the actions of the perpetrator was OK, Bad or Severe.
If the majority of Guardians vote OK, no action is taken, if they vote Bad, then the perpetrator is muted for 15 mins and is banned from the room they were reported in, if they vote Severe, and a Moderator looks at the case and decides what action to take.
it's all explained here: http://blog.habbo.com/2012/08/13/cur...bbo-guardians/
I think it works well! Obviously you will get abuse with a system like this but I think it'll work if they make "Guardian" level tighter than what it is. Maybe a flag system as well if you abuse xx amount of times then you get removed for xx amount of time.This^
!) I don't know why people are complaining about how long chatlogs are, you need them to see the whole story lol. Otherwise it'll probably be how the mods these days seem to do it (spot a word and then ban :rolleyes- sarcasm fgs. It may not be interesting to read through it all but it wouldn't be that hard to spot a username
2) Why the **** has everyone had the chance to get it. I know a large majority are going to give honest votes, but the Habbo Helper system got trolled so much and this will be abused just as much. Poor users who have done nothing wrong (e.g. in Red's case said "shut up") are going to be punished if a load of insanely strict Guardians come along all on one case. Like the Safety Patrol but even worse. People will be punished for saying "crap" at this rate tbf.
3) It looks nice and modern, it's genuinely a good look and well designed but it shouldn't be just given out left right and centre to those that can earn a few 'achievements' now and then.
Paul LaFontaine has seriously brought me to the brink of rage. Yes I know someone will say "excuse me you all wanted something like Hobbas back!"!!"!£!" and we did, but an introductory system like this is just stupid. Another reason why I'm not active on the hotel that much anymore lol.
The bold bit is supposedly meant to happen. Says on the blog abusers will get temp. removed. Trouble is, once they go back in they can just **** about with the system again. Not to mention different ages have a different level of opinion upon "abuse", a 13 year old may find "omg you're so crap at this bb game" offense whereas a 16 year old wouldn't tbh. I would have dramatically fell in love with it if there had been an age limit but then again, hard to prove your age :L
Not to mention I'm incredibly opposed to it being earnt simply via achievements. Everything is ach. based and I dislike it =/ is there any other stage after guardians or not for now?
/
If you falsely report someone (ie. the vote is all "OK"), then the person that reported will get a "dont abuse the system" warning and a few times after, you are prevented from reporting a bully for a short amount of time.
---------- Post added 13-08-2012 at 12:24 PM ----------
Let's hope the last "TBD" stage is more difficult.
Need to earn 12 more recommendations and handle 45 more help requests, this is time consuming!
For those interested, Here is an official blog post explaining how the Habbo Guardian system works.
http://blog.habbo.com/2012/08/13/cur...bbo-guardians/
Want to hide these adverts? Register an account for free!