Music - CD Or Live?

[RainFall.]

To be totally honest. Some Artists are great on CD, but not very good in Live peformances. I cant do it myself so I dont want to be patronising.

Lets take for instance Black Eyed Peas. When they reformed the band with Fergie (The Female!).. The 6th single " Dont Lie " came out in Summer 2005. She sang great on the actual CD track but she wasn't very good live.

When " My Humps " broadcasted on the music channels in October, I thought that Fergie has a great voice. When she peformed on CDUK and Record Of The Year, I thought she didnt do so well.

So the whole concept is..

What artists are best at. Live or CD?

[Dupion]

CD but I like live also.

[ross]

CD but I like live also.

[Rawr]

Well on CD it's all spruised up with computers to make it sound better. Muse are a amazing band live if you have ever seen/heard them live.

[0verRide]

CD, when live all you can hear is the fat women next to you

[the wombats]

Well when I watched ''the record of the year 2005'' earlier, I thought half the bands wre rubbish, so I think CD is better, but that is just my opinion

[Adam$]

I like CDs. I only like live if I'm actually there. I hate hearing live songs on CD. :\

[Loaned]

Weird Al was great live. He sounded like he did on CD, so it just depends on the singer.

[Rosie]

Seedee .

[RainFall.]

I am listening to My Humps right now xP