Really annoying Qeustion !!!!

[partie2]

If a Tree Falls in forest and nobody hears it fall does.it make a sound ?

[Luayminator]

Yes it does , but people dont pay attention

[-JT-]

of course it makes a noise, by the laws of physics movment is energy which can not be destroyed. Therfor it must change from one form to another, e.g. sound. The falling tree causes vibrations wich is what the human ear picks up and hears.

By the laws of physics, yes there will be a sound.

[Corey777]

But how can it make a sound if no one is there to hear it?

[Jane]

I could talk now, and you wouldnt hear it, does that mean I'm not making a noice? Its the same for the tree.

[Corey777]

I could talk now, and you wouldnt hear it, does that mean I'm not making a noice? Its the same for the tree.

There is someone there to hear it though, yourself. So that point wouldn't hold up.

[ideabox]

Listen. Trees fall that makes a noise. We dont have to hear it for it to make a noise now? What about the big bang? No one was there to hear it or if a rock falls into a sea it makes a noise but not loud enouth to hear for us! There is noise all around us.

[Jane]

Anyway, if a tree hits the ground it causes vibrations, which = noise. It doesn't matter if no one hears it, it still makes a sound

[Concentric]

But if nothing is there to detect it then you cannot prove that it does. You assume that it will because that's what would happen if you were there to witness it, but if you're not then you can't prove that it does anything.

[:.bEx.:]

I think it makes a sound cause well theres still a sound...
And anyway there could be bugs in the tree that wd hear it..and u neva no it aint been proven that trees dont ave ears just like humans! :p