beyonce or shakira?

[hobo]

i thought about this cos on the youtube videos of their song Beautiful Liar there's loads of debating over who's better.
(and loads of dissing beyonce cos she doesn't actually do the belly dancing, they use a mirror effect on shakira's body apparantly)

so, who do you prefer?
tbh i prefer shakira, beyonce's songs all kind of sound the same to me, and they get annoying reeeeeally fast.
the only one i really like is Irreplaceable.

so ye?

oh and here's the link for their song together, incase you haven't heard it. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RtIHBRsy1lI

[Barkseh2131]

shakira is wat i'd call perfect.

[Browney]

Easy Shakira. Her dancing and her body are fantastic. Oh yeah, her voice isn't bad either.

Proof if needed: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CD6JsdJnC_8

[,Jess,]

I think shakira has a more erm.. interesting voice. Her songs are quite catchy but after a while her voice grates on me

Beyonce has a good voice.. and I like some of her older stuff from a couple of years back like crazy in love because it's just a good summer tune.

I don't like either of them loads but i would have to say that I prefer Beyonce

[summer]

Beyonce is much better than Shakira! You're all madddd.

[dirrty]

beyonce. but i like shakira aswell.

also beyonces music is better than shakiras, but hips dont lie is just bare gd.

[English]

Beyonce is so much better than Shakira!

[benjamin]

BEYONCE X

[summer]

BEYONCE X

Beyonce is so much better than Shakira!

Good boys! -clap-

[--ss--]

Isit me or in hips don't lie did shakira sound like a man?
tbh i perfer beyonce.