Which Jacket to buy?

[LoveToStack]

Right, birthday is coming up so I need to decide which of these jackets to get and I need some advice.
These are the candidates:

Carhartt, comes in at £85 which is expensive but it's really nice;


Here's the same jacket in navy, also nice:


Harrington jacket, £60 for a Ben Sherman one, could pay £75 for a Merc one but it's not worth the extra £15;



Also comes in cream;



Opinions welcome! I know they're all kind of the same but that's the look I'm going for. Cheers.

[Tristan]

Any but the third one. Top two style looks so nice!!
Out of all, I would go for brown top one. Although it is a lot of money...

[Xtina]

I would go for the second one. But if you want a warmer jacket go for the third one ;p

[LoveToStack]

It's mainly something light for summer so they're all fairly light. The third one is the same material and thickness as the fourth one, just couldn't get a decent picture of it like that but it's not as heavy as it looks.
I really like the top two as well, ideally it'd be both but atm I'm swaying towards navy. Doesn't seem very summery though. Also it's majorly expensive lol.

[Xtina]

Oh, if it were between the first and second one, I'd go for the second one

[Sharon]

Second one definately. I don't like the 1st 3rd and 4th much but REALLY don't like the first.

[Roxy]

Second is my favourite

[Xtina]

Just out of curiosity, what does it say on the top 2 jackets?

[LoveToStack]

Just out of curiosity, what does it say on the top 2 jackets?

Carhartt

[Tristan]

Actually, yeah. Second one.
It depends on what other clothes you wear, the colour clothes I were would probably mean I suit the first one more but generally, yeah second.