Which side of the Punk argument are you on

[~Hilton~]

Are you on the side that supports Good Charlotte, Simple Plan, etc. Or the side that supports Rancid, NOFX, Bad Religion, The Ramones etc.


_____

Post your arguments in here.

[Rashelly]

Why did you make another thread for this? it's annoying how many threads are about "punk" as it is, and the same things get said again and again on them.
Oh but I had a funny PM on here the other week, because in one post I wrote "*** pistols are one of the worst punk bands" anyway, it was this girl who said "my dad said to tell you to take a history lesson because *** pistols were the begining of punk"
that made me laugh for almost a minute.
Wow that had nothing to do with this thread...but oh well.
and I don't agree with people calling bands "posers" they're just doing their job! and making a lot of money! they're not forcing anyone to listen to them.
I think you should add a third option to the poll, the "i don't give a rats behind just give me any music with a twotone beat!"
or maybe without the two tone beat part, because most probably wont get that reference :/
Oh look...I seem to have posted another long boring comment again.

[XxHuggsxX]

How Would I Vote.. I Listen To All That.. I do Liosten To Poser Punk.. And i Dont Care What You Guyz think.. But I Do Listen To Like Nofx And The Ramones.. I Like Anti Flag And All That

[Wobegong]

No of them they all Stink !

[Jane]

Punk pop rulez, I am a lame wad who owns a toilet pass.

[:.Jenny.:]

Punk is punk dammit.
Stop killing this topic.

[Victimized]

I listen to Rancid, Bad Religion, NOFX and that. Do Less Than Jake come under Real Punk Rock? They should do, i love them.

[Jim Rotates]

^^ they're Ska...which I guess is Punk with a reggae twist so yeah...

[Victimized]

Oh i just don't know anymore! Too many subgenres.

By the way: 500th POST! Woot Woot!
And before anyone says it, yes i know it's sad to get worked up about postcount, and for your concern i am just having a laugh. Sorry but these days you get jumped on for making a spelling mistake!

[xJoeYx]

rashelly the pistols were a major punk icon and possibly the most popular... i hate them though, i think they sound awful screaming their stupid anarchistic views.
In response to the thread, i really think real punk is the only punk, definetly not any of this GD rubbish.