Microsoft sued over use of live tiles in Windows

[HotelUser]

http://www.pcworld.com/article/20133...n-windows.html

Microsoft has been slapped with a patent infringement lawsuit over its use of dynamic “live” tile icons in Windows, including in the newly launched Windows 8 OS for PCs and tablets and in the Windows Phone 8 OS for smartphones.SurfCast, based in Portland, Maine, filed its lawsuit on Tuesday in the U.S. District Court for the District of Maine, and is asking for Microsoft to pay an undetermined amount of money in damages and attorneys’ fees.
At issue is U.S. Patent 6,724,403, titled “System and Method for Simultaneous Display of Multiple Information Sources,” which SurfCast was awarded in 2004.
SurfCast takes issue with Windows’ use of live tiles, which are rectangular or square icons in the Start screen of new Windows versions that provide links to applications, websites, contacts and other elements. SurfCast describes itself on its website as a designer of OS technology. It claims to have developed the live tile technology in the 1990s.
In a statement, Microsoft said it was “confident” it would prove in court that SurfCast's claims are without merit and that Microsoft has created a “unique user experience.”
Unlike conventional icons, live tiles display dynamically-changing data about the element it links to, such as the number of unread messages in users’ email inboxes and alerts about new notifications from their social networking accounts.
Live tiles are a key user interface feature in a variety of new Windows versions, including Windows 8, Windows 8 Pro, Windows Phone 8 and Windows RT, which is a Windows 8 version for devices that use ARM chips. Microsoft first used live tiles in Windows Phone 7.
Starting with Windows 7 and most significantly with the just-launched Windows 8 OS family, Microsoft redesigned the Windows user interface around the use of these tile icons, so as to optimize the OS for use with touchscreen tablets and smartphones.
Windows is a minor player in tablets and smartphones, whose sales have been booming in the past three years. Google’s Android and Apple’s iOS are the main OSes used in tablets and smartphones.

Thoughts?

[Tomm]

Company seems like some patent troll, their website is from 2001 and the only "news" is from this October announcing their intent to sue Microsoft. In my opinion (obviously won't happen) the case should be instantly dismissed with prejudice simply based on the fact they don't make or do anything with their patents apart from use them as the basis to sue people.

[xxMATTGxx]

YAY another silly court case. It will either be thrown out or Microsoft will just throw some money at them. I doubt they will do what they did with the metro name, although the full details of that was never brought to the public.

[GommeInc]

Just another pointless patent. The case should be dismissed, it's taken them so many years to notice and they clearly have no use for live tiles.

[RyRy]

Probably another settlement case.

[Plucked]

It's a bit pathetic really.. ah well!

[peteyt]

Just another pointless patent. The case should be dismissed, it's taken them so many years to notice and they clearly have no use for live tiles.

Was about to say this. If its true you think they would have done something when windows phone began to use it.

[TheDylan13]

Company seems like some patent troll, their website is from 2001 and the only "news" is from this October announcing their intent to sue Microsoft. In my opinion (obviously won't happen) the case should be instantly dismissed with prejudice simply based on the fact they don't make or do anything with their patents apart from use them as the basis to sue people.

I completely agree.

[efq]

What next. People are getting desperate for money and suing left right and center.