DISCUSS X FACTOR 2011

peteyt · 12-11-2011, 01:59 PM

Originally Posted by Stephen!

People complaining because someone who got sent out in the first week sings one song and gets an instant place in the last 7(?) when all the other contestants had to sing their absolute best to stay in numerous times

or

People complaining because the person who got voted out by the judges and not the public a few days before frankie got booted out returns

If they did let johnny return then the risk fans could easily get their complaints squashed by the fact that the risk got the lowest votes on sunday anyway

But we all know Johnny won't stand a chance. He has done in the live shows one good song.

**Stephen** · 12-11-2011, 02:18 PM

What has johnny not standing a chance got to do with it? I'm going by fairness

geo · 13-11-2011, 11:12 AM

I think Craig's performances are just getting better and better right now, I want to see him in the final!

Also, Kitty was fab!

peteyt · 13-11-2011, 12:26 PM

Originally Posted by Stephen!

What has johnny not standing a chance got to do with it? I'm going by fairness

The truth is he should never have gotten through. Yeah he is nice and funny but I doubt he will succeed. The X Factor is a music competition and by letting people in who don't stand a chance it just makes it feel like a huge let down just to get ratings and makes me and I know others to, disrespect the show. I do think Louie Walsh is part of the problem - he was going to let Goldie through and she would have been on the live shows if she hadn't dropped out yet I can't think of many if any, that would go out and buy her album.